I Gott… I don’t know… Lost?
I’ve been going back and forth on this episode. Not on my feelings about the episode, but whether I should sugar coat those feelings in this post. And I decided that I just can’t. When I love an episode, I love it like a two week old puppy… and when I don’t, I just don’t.
I can’t get into the whole Eloise Hawking stuff. I don’t know, it’s just too much exposition. Too much standing around talking about why things are the way they are. And maybe it’s the cape, but don’t her scenes have a bit of a Dark Shadows feel to them?… which is cool I guess, but seems a little odd for this show. But maybe some of you feel the same about all the archaeological stuff. I have to admit, next week’s episode does look very Temple of Doom. Yikes.
I don’t know. Is it’s cause the storyline involves Faraday? His time-space stuff is so heady, maybe they’re afraid of losing people without lots of explanation. That look Kate gave him while he was explaining Variables vs Constants was priceless.
Anyway, the episode was very “blah” for me. Particularly the stuff with Des and Penny, which felt like scenes from a completely different episode. I love that storyline, but I just don’t think they earned the sentimentality of that last scene, do you?
- They weren’t in the episode much.
- We already saw him beat the hell out of Ben in a fairly “alive” state.
- It was a bullet wound to the shoulder… I mean, can you imagine a character on this show dying that soon from a bullet wound to the shoulder? Desmond??! I can’t. And I didn’t.
And of course the gunfight at the OK Corral. *sigh*
So does it mean the episode yielded nothing to me. Of course not. One thing’s for sure, my parallel universe theory is still firmly in tact… even if my “that’s not a fake plane on the ocean floor” theory is starting to get a little wobbly. Starting, though! There’s still plenty of lying holding that sucker up.
Did you guys see the issue of Wired Magazine on Faraday’s couch? If not, here’s a close up of it.

As you can imagine, I’m a very loyal Wired subscriber, and that particular issue is familiar. It’s from August 2003. And the coolest thing about the issue, as it relates to this episode, is a rather fascinating article about Time Travel, and one particularly interesting part about something called a Gott Shell. I’m not gonna give you the full down and dirty, but I thought this little bit was a standout.
Having examined Einstein’s equations more closely, physicists now realize that the river of time may be diverted into a whirlpool – called a closed timelike curve – or even a fork leading to a parallel universe. In particular, the more mass you can concentrate at a single point, the more you can bend the flow.
And now we have Faraday rethinking his entire concept of time… wondering if maybe he can change things (sorry, recycling lines from older posts.) Of course, as he’s telling this to little Charlotte, I’m sure he realizes the conversation itself was already fore(or aft)told by older Charlotte. So what change does he think he can make?
Oh and Eloise cracks Widmore good when he refers to Daniel as his son. She had no problem calling Penny his daughter… so clearly different mothers. I have a feeling that Eloise is already pregnant in this episode. In fact, I think she and Charles are a couple at this point. My hunch is that Charles will send her away to raise Daniel off the Island. Probably part of a strategy to save the Island in the long run… she may even wind up on the submarine that’s leaving soon.
And, I don’t know why, maybe it’s just the similar looks of the actresses… but I have this feeling Charles will start to romance Juliette (The Outsider) and get her pregnant with Penny. Whoa, if I’m right, what if there’s an older Juliette running around?!
And after watching this episode, here are my burning questions:
- I want to know what the experiment was that put Faraday’s girlfriend in the coma.
- He says he tested it out on himself first. Is that what caused his deteriorating mental state… or is it something else?
- I’m wondering if the reason Faraday finds the crash on TV so moving, is because he lived through something that he can no longer remember. Another time and space, maybe? Could Faraday be in some sort of time loop?
So hit me up. What did you all think? 100th episode grade? I know some of you already tweeted me that you liked it, so maybe it’s just me.
Oh, and Part 2 of my Deciphering Lost’s Hieroglyphs series is coming very soon.
Related articles by Zemanta
- A layman’s guide to Time Travel – Part 1 or why Einstein’s General Theory of Relativity is a Trojan Horse. (talatfakhri.com)
- Jay Glatfelter: On Lost “The Variable” (huffingtonpost.com)
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=952eb4a7-508e-4b29-8750-a6cfedcb4397)

Hanna on 01 May 2009 at 12:02 am #
I kinda liked this epi but not really, for me this was like back to s3. Solid good but not really that great. Faraday is such an interesting character for me anyway, or could be, but think they wasted this episode. Until this point I’ve enjoyed Eloise but this painted her as a lame version of Ben, manipulating ppl but totally not in a cool way. Not that manipulating is a good/cool thing IMO but from a storytelling point of view. Also the whole gunfight was stupid. One thing I liked was the whole Juliette-Kate-Sawyer thing back at their house. Also I thought the thing with Faraday and the news was pretty nice. Cause that kind of thing happens for us real ppl anyway LOL We see something and instantly feel connected to something new and start to wonder why or maybe even remember something. So I liked that part too.
ashley on 01 May 2009 at 12:06 am #
Personally I really liked the episode, but I’m fascinated by Faraday so getting another centric episode was just good to me. I thought it was pretty great seeing that Dan was coming back to try and stop the incident so there would never be a button, a crash, etc. They obviously used the 100th episode to set up for the next huge storyline — trying to stop the future from happening the way it already had (has happened, did happen, could happen? I don’t know). I think it was a good turning episode, definitely full of a few good shocks for me, though. Charles being Dan’s dad, yeah, I didn’t see that coming.
I love the Penny/Desmond line, and I always enjoy seeing them, but it was very out of place to me, too.
But I love your Penny/Juliette theory, and the theory about Dan being so moved about the footage of the plane being found. That scene always captures my interest, I love the idea that he’s so upset because he’s involved with that (or something like it) somehow and can’t remember because of his mental state. It makes me think that maybe Dan was upset because he remembered (or was feeling it, but failed to remember) a different time/space where he was on the island in the 1970s with everyone on that plane, and instead of them crashing on the island, they “crashed in the ocean”. He even said something along the lines of, “It’s just so sad, they’re all dead,” could it make sense? Far fetched? Yes, but that’s what theories are made of.
SarahSamudre on 01 May 2009 at 1:04 am #
Alright, I feel the SAME way. Good and meh.
What I didn’t like-
A) I don’t like the actress. She was amazing as mysterious, “you can’t propose to Penny” master of the universe’s knowledge, Mrs Hawking in Season 3. But the last several times we’ve seen her, I’ve honestly thought she hams up almost every line she’s in. And the girl they got to play middle aged Ellie is even hammier.
B) The episode felt kind of wasted to me. Dan obviously went crazy when Charlotte died, and has spent three years trying to fight what he can’t. Kinda pointless because Guy Genius didn’t factor in the truth that Mrs Hawking started the time traveling story line with: The UNIVERSE course corrects.
Even if Oceanic 815 doesn’t crash, Widmore will still send a freighter to the Island to find Ben, because (I don’t know why Dan overlooked this) going to the island wasn’t about the survivors. Ben is the issue, and if Sayid can’t kill Ben to avoid the future complications with him, Dan can’t stop this conflict either. Not to mention, the button may have crashed the plane, but by that time the plane was already MYSTERIOUSLY 100s of miles off course.
The island gets what the island wants.
3) I will say I liked the Juliet/Sawyer stuff, and I’m glad that at least for know, they’re keeping the storyline away from the love square/triangle plot. At least until she gets shot. Which I’m afraid of.
Maybe it’s just because we’re theorizers, but most Lost fans already saw the big aha! moments coming- like you said, it was just really nice to hear them confirm them.
I hope next week is better than what it looks like. Jack trying to control things (again) by carrying out Dan’s grief-fueled cockamamie scheme just looks annoying. But the good part? It looks like we’re also going to see Locke and Ben. Which always is reason for rejoicing.
Honestly, maybe I just need them to rename Lost “BEN”. All Ben, all the time. That would make me happy. Add a bit of Hurley and it’s magic.
Stephanie on 01 May 2009 at 1:37 am #
My biggest question – and maybe that’s because I wasn’t caffeinated when I watched it – is, why did Eloise send him back there if she knew he’d get shot?
Mike on 01 May 2009 at 5:07 am #
Wasn’t a huge fan of this ep, and as a bookend to “The Constant” it didn’t hold up at all. As far as Faraday, I’m pretty sure the experiment he did on himself and his girlfriend was the same experiment he did on his rat eloise. Theresa was time jumping if I remember right. So my guess is that if he tried it on himself first, then his consciousness, like desmonds in the constant, was jumping between where he was presently, and a version of himself on the island. Since he knows desmond in both times, he found a constant and stabilized, but his memory loss was a side effect. so when he’s crying at the wreckage, i think it’s because part of him knows he knows the people on it, and he now thinks they’re dead. I didn’t like his whole change of theory with time travel. I feel like they just threw that in to screw with the audience a bit, or write themselves out of a hole. By telling charlotte not to come back to the island, he’s just upholding what already happened not changing it. Plus, 1977 is the past, yet it’s also their present, so to change the past’s future, is also to change their present’s past, and according to his rules, an impossibility. And how is a hydrogen bomb less catastrophic than the Incident. I liked the Eloise stuff. They need to give us more, but i think she’s gonna play a part at the swan, get dosed with some electromagnetism, and start having her flashes much like Desmond. If anything, I’d say the only variable is Desmond. Things seem to work differently for him, he noticed the time flash when faraday talks to him at the hatch, no one else (Richard, rousseau) did, and he sort of can change the future, not the outcome (charlie dies) but how it happens. I think he’s going to be very important. And I agree with you John, he and Penny didn’t earn that scene at the end. Maybe if they had been in the previous couple of episodes, it wouldn’t have seemed so forced. Was like they were trying to recreate “The Constant”. It fell flat.
Johnny Hugel on 01 May 2009 at 6:15 am #
Maybe I’m not drinking enough caffeine when I rehash the episodes, but nothing’s really grabbed my interest in a while and instead I’ve been appreciating each episode at relatively face value.
A question I have is where did Daniel go and why after Charlotte died? If he really went to Harvard, it was the 70′s off island, correct? It would have been in THIS time period that he would have changed his mind about some of his experiments and his ability to affect time, not in the 90′s – 2000′s when we see him in this episode. Wouldn’t his mental state have reverted to how it had been off island? How did he solve anything in that state? (And who sent him the fax of Jack and Co in the class photo? )
I thought showing how mentally unstable he was was an interesting turn and a great performance from Jeremy Davies, one that is unexpected in a typical sci-fi show like this. On the other hand I agree that Eloise was pretty ehh (as was Daniel’s 80′s hair).
In the future does Ellie work in conjunction with Widmore, or do they both represent the interests of the island against whoever the other force is that is trying to find it?
Meredith on 01 May 2009 at 6:40 am #
Meh, I agree wtih you on the overall feel of the episode and the Penny/Desmond scenes. The whole time they were playing I was trying to figure out why they slowed down the whole episode with that.
I caught and loved the little Wired mini-plug….In the most recent issue, JJ Abrams was the guest editor and had a big article so it was nice to see a little acknowledgement of that haha.
dumptruck molly on 01 May 2009 at 7:47 am #
i liked the episode, but i’m not terribly picky about LOST and love most of everything they give me. i trust their vision and enjoy the ride.
i was terribly annoyed that Faraday and the gang took guns with them. ummm… have they learned nothing? you don’t go to the Others with guns and act all crazy, that gets you shot every time.
i loved the stuff with Desmond and Penny, as always. i love Eloise and want to know more about her history and what her connection to everything is. she scares me and fascinates me all at the same time. i mean, she’s hardcore if she sent her son back to the Island knowing full well that she shoots and possibly kills him (i’m not certain he’s dead).
i don’t like your theory of Charles wooing Juliette. i’m not saying that it couldn’t happen (because I thought it was a crap idea that Charles be Faraday’s father), but I don’t like it at all. that whole idea just creeps me out.
i love the idea of them changing the past and how that will impact their future. it’s really interesting to think about… what would their lives be like if none of this had ever happened? i think their lives would be really pathetic, even though things aren’t going well for them at this particular moment. but seriously… i think they were all supposed to end up there. and through being stubborn jerks (Jack) they’ve managed to screw everything up.
and also… if they change the past, what happens? do they disappear? do they remember what has happened? or…. could this be how your beloved alternate reality comes about?
i love that you’re still holding onto the hope of that plane being real…. but i’m quite certain it’s a fake. i suppose they could be lying, but really, i doubt it. but i admire your conviction!
but yeah, overall this episode didn’t leave me feeling much excitement, or give me much to talk about, but i still enjoyed it. i had a few “oh, snap!” moments. but… overall… kind of disappointing for a 100th episode.
Pauline on 01 May 2009 at 9:23 am #
Isn’t the experiment that put Theresa, Faraday’s girlfriend, in a coma (I know, I know – its really serious) the one from the episode “The Constant” where they sent the rat’s consciousness into the future using equations from Faraday’s notebook supplied to him by Desmond? I was wondering when we were going to get the backstory for how Theresa ended up in a hospital bed in Jughead.
This ep was really uneven for me. I love Faraday but his mom is a big freaking Yawn. & while I love Desmond, I find his eps as boring as the Luke and Laura story line has been since the mid 90′s. I LOVE that Faraday is the lovechild of Ellie and Charles but if this is a war for the island based on passion and betrayal (Chuck knocking up an outsider) the two have played it so dully. (except for the slap.) I mean, hell hath no fury like a woman scorned right? And Ellie acts more like she’s just constipated or something most of the time.
Thanks for posting that bit from Wired. I love the imagery of our (now) time castaways caught in a whirlpool. And I love where it is going in terms of the dilemma our castaways will now have. To change or not to change time. I mean, to go back to an ordinary life and never know all that they know now? For one… Kate will go back to LA a captive and never know the love of her adopted child.
Oh… and I’m with Ashley… Faraday is totally remembering, on an emotional level anyway, his tie with the 815 survivors and the guilt that his time jumping may have caused it. I think Faraday has been hopping around in time for a long time.
Great theory about Juliet and Chuck, j. Although the time traveling implications of that are too heady for me to really contemplate at this juncture. In fact, the whole idea of temporal displacement that this ep brought up again with Theresa is hurting my temporal lobe.
ouch.
Pauline on 01 May 2009 at 10:59 am #
OMG! Mike! You just totally reminded me! I had completely forgotten about Desmond’s ability to know Charlie’s future.
Thanks!
kelseroo on 01 May 2009 at 2:18 pm #
This has nothing to do with the episode (I haven’t actually watched it yet) but did anyone take the “Which Lost character are you” test on Facebook? Guess who I got… Hurley. Perfect fit. Especially since I watch Lost in a Hurley fashion.
John Cabrera on 01 May 2009 at 5:59 pm #
P and Mike, yeah I figured that it was the same experiment as on the rat… but I’m just wondering exactly what it was. I mean, Desmond experienced the same effects that the rat did by flying through the threshold of the Island’s cashmere effect. Wasn’t the rat being treated with something? I guess I’m just eager to see that scene and how it actually takes place. I imagine kinda gruesome, no?
But those three burning questions are really more of a Cabrera-way of throwing out another… shall we say… hunch (cause I’m sneaky/cowardly like that). I guess what I’m wondering is whether during that experiment, Daniel BEGAN his story with the survivors on the Island. We all assume that his story began with him parachuting onto the island… but my guess is that it actually began
in the 80s(not in the 80s but whenever that was, late 90s or something), when he did the experiment on himself. It most likely took him backwards in time (like it did Desmond)… And as you pointed out Mike, since he exists in the 70s, it could have taken him there.If so his mind would have been as intact as it was during his years at university… but it would have begun to deteriorate the more he flashed back to the island. So compare Faraday just after Charlotte’s death (a mumbling broken man) with the sturdy focused man who comes off of the Sub from Ann Arbor. And as the episode progresses… he starts to twitch… something we didn’t see just off the sub… or in the underground Orchid. I think these are Faradays from two different mental times. If so, he may be stuck. I have a feeling we’re going to see him again.
John Cabrera on 01 May 2009 at 6:03 pm #
DumpTruck, glad you’re liking the possibility of a changing universe… I remember a few weeks back you were pretty die hard on the “everything that happened happened” thing.
I think we’re starting to see that everything that happened didn’t necessarily happen EXACTLY the same every time. Forks of parallel universes as the Wired article puts it. Except, as you pointed out, sarahsamudre, the UNIVERSE course corrects… which means it wants things to be as close as possible. Which may be why Eloise wanted as many of the survivors on that plane as possible… to match. And if that plane on the ocean floor is indeed a fake, this could explain why it’s a fake… because perhaps, Widmore needs it to match an alternate universe where sadly… it was not a fake… one that Faraday witnessed.
We keep hearing, “what the Island wants” “or “the healing properties of the Island” But I’m starting to think it’s not what the Island wants… I think it’s what the Universe wants. The Universe wants things to be course corrected. Not the Island. The Universe prevents Michael from killing himself. And Hugel, I think the Universe may be healing these people, on… or off The Island. And so if I’m right about these alternate Universes… The Island itself would the biggest “constant” between them.
I don’t know… maybe.
Kels, I haven’t done mine yet, who wants to guess what it’ll be?
Hanna, yes, clearly the show is making a subtle connection to real world Deja Vu. I love that, and agree Huges, Davies played the scene very well.
Oh and sarahsamudre, a plastic toy from the 80s?! Late 80s maybe… first few years, Transformers were metal, yo. Sorry was that outta place here?
Pauline on 01 May 2009 at 6:17 pm #
If possible… I’d guess you Faraday in the quiz… But he may not be an option. Maybe Juliet? Charlie?
I’ll probably end up as Charlie. Perhaps Miles if the option is there.
Smartacus on 01 May 2009 at 7:36 pm #
So this last episode made me wonder (either I’m confused or just not paying enough attention) is this last bit with Faraday his second go-round in the 70′s? We saw him with Dr. Chang down where they’re drilling and the worker is talking about how silly time travel is, going back to kill Hitler, etc. but none of the Oceanic 6 were with him then. Are we watching the same thing from a slightly different p.o.v. or was he there before and went back AGAIN to try and change the doctor’s mind about the project based on his new theory?
leah on 01 May 2009 at 8:46 pm #
I don’t have any kids, but if I did I would say “hey son when you see me in the past don’t have a gun!”
Also Daniel wanting to change the whole plane crashing REALLY bothers me. Doesn’t this bother anyone else? I mean not for the whole “I love the show” I mean for the characters. Rose would die. Aaron would of been adopted out. Sawyer would still be a prick. Kate would be on death row or in prison forever. I could go on. I know there is a lot of negative things that have happened. But it has given people second chances.
My last two cents is I don’t think Juliette is Penny’s mom. Ahole got kicked off the island, I thought, for sleeping with someone who wasn’t on the island at all.
Plus why was he never involved with Daniel….and allow him to get killed?
Episode left a bad taste in my mouth. Love all the lost, but arg!
John Cabrera on 01 May 2009 at 9:05 pm #
Leah, actually, Ben doesn’t say he slept with someone off the Island. He says he slept with an outsider. And when the writers are that ambiguous it’s usually because they want us to think we heard “someone off the Island.” That will allow them to either a.) surprise us with an “Outsider” who we already know… or b.) hold off on making a clear choice for who they want it to be. It’s probably the latter. And if the fans start demanding a cool answer to that, they’re gonna have to supply it… and you can bet it’s not gonna be some random new character.
Pauline on 01 May 2009 at 10:53 pm #
I think Faraday wanting to change the past is going to open up a lot of internal debate for our characters ~ at least that is what I’m hoping. After the things they’ve been through, and all that they know now about time, the universe, themselves and their purpose, if I were one of them, I wouldn’t want to go back to my own ordinary life. In fact, I have been thinking lately about what I’d do if I had the option of going to the Lost island in order to get rid of my several diseases and disorders. I have no idea but I suspect the decision will be even harder for our 815 survivors.
I do feel like Faraday would have been smart enough to not even attempt to change things, knowing it would become a total mess. I definitely think that Faraday is stuck in a time loop now though. I’d say I hoped he watched a lot of episodes of “Tru Calling” in 2003 but he’d lack the recall for it to have helped any with his spacetime continuum issues.
I still don’t know whether Ellie knew she was shooting her son or not. That actress has those big googly eyes like Allison on this cycle’s ANTM and I couldn’t read her emotions at all.
Oh… and is this the second time Faraday is telling Chang to evacuate..? because Chang didn’t sound thrilled with the idea… yet he’d already done it the first time around… sooooo…
I’m Claire by the way. :p
Mike on 02 May 2009 at 10:54 am #
I think them showing us Faraday and Chang down in the Orchid wasn’t a new take on what we’ve already seen, it was just the “why we saw it” as the premiere opener.
John, I think the rat was just being exposed to heavy doses of electromagnetism, which sent it’s mind forward a couple of hours. With Desmond, after he was dosed at the hatch, leaving the threshold of the island just triggered the same effect.
The more I think about Faraday the more I get confused. I think we’re missing a scene or something. I agree John that his time with the Island exists prior to his physical arrival on it. His conscious has to have been time jumping since he tried the experiment on himself, how and when it stabilized is what I want to see. Maybe how it happened for him wasn’t the way it happened for Desmond and instead of one consciousness replacing another, maybe it sort of split down the middle in Faraday’s head. I don’t know. We know Desmond is his constant, but the thing with that is that Faraday doesn’t know that until 2004. I’m pretty sure that when Des went through his ordeal, he was creating new memories. With him, whatever happened, didn’t always happen, cause if it did, his 2004 self would have been aware of needing Penny’s number, and the boat coming, etc. So if I’m right, then Faraday doesn’t meet Desmond at Oxford until Faraday on the island tells Desmond to go meet him at Oxford. I’m wondering now, if that when Desmond was trying to find his constant, a time jumping Faraday unknowingly found his, and stabilized his off island self sometime in the 90′s. This way, when he reads in his journal that if anything happens Des is his constant, it’s not so much a foreshadowing of something that might happen, but more a reasoning for Faraday that why what was going on with him, no longer is.
Hopefully that makes some kind of sense, I’m writing this mostly to get it out of my head, cause It’s driving me nuts trying to figure it all out.
SarahSamudre on 02 May 2009 at 12:07 pm #
Ouch John.
You’re right. I dunno what I was thinking.
*Is this you getting me back for being right about Desmond? ;P
John Cabrera on 02 May 2009 at 1:30 pm #
LOL. The moment I saw the blood on his shoulder I said, “awww shit!” and thus began searching for something to take you down.
DJSmackMackey on 04 May 2009 at 6:23 am #
Ok, I’m late to the game, but I thought I’d throw in my thoughts.
I actually don’t think Penny was overreacting. Her husband was SHOT!! If your spouse were shot, don’t you think you’d be in hysterics. Especially if the guy who shot him almost shot you too? in front of your kid? So Penny being upset and worried, not far fetched at all.
Secondly, did no one else notice that Eloise was left alone with Charlie?!? She’s totally gonna kidnap him!
Also, I loved this episode. I know a lot of you feel differently, but I really found it great. For one thing, ever since Back to the Future, I’ve been known to stay up at night contemplating time. I don’t know enough about physics and the laws of the universe, but I do love thinking about it. And what I feel is that, it is impossible to change your own timeline. So there’s no logical way that the plane could never crash on the island for the survivors that we know. You could only make it happen or not happen in another timeline. A parallel universe. So there’s always the possibility of multiverse storyline coming up, though I hope the show doesn’t turn into Sliders.
JR Tschopp on 04 May 2009 at 6:27 am #
On the whole, the episode just kind of left me wanting more. It felt like they were trying to set up the finale more than progress the overall story along. Which is fine, I suppose, but it really seemed like the episode would have been better served being viewed with the last three hours of this season than as a stand-alone installment.
I do like the Faraday time-jumping theory; making him the Billy Pilgrim of “Lost” would be rather interesting.
Micah on 04 May 2009 at 6:38 am #
I agree, it wasn’t as good as I thought it would be for the 100th ep, it just felt like it was rehashing storylines rather than really moving forward. I mean we all new Eloise was Dan’s mother, I did like the twist that Charles is his father…Like your theory about Juliet too John – should be interestin.
I did wish that when Faraday told Chang that Miles was his son, that he would have listened more, questioned him etc, I mean he is looking into time travel theories yet he believed Miles pathetic excuse of too much drugs on the sub. Don’t you think he would have wanted to look at Dan’s equations??? He is a hardcore scientist. Maybe they’ll come back to that, maybe Chang will think about it and then question Miles. If Hurley was around he would have backed Dan up.
I wish now that James and Juliet are captured they will spill the beans about being from the future to save themselves, like Sawyer did to Richard to save them earlier. I would like to see that play out. Also I loved the way Juliet took control and told Kate to help Dan…like she was
marking her territory with Sawyer. Funny as.
Overall the ep was fine, but needed more of our
main core characters to be included, this story was
centered around newer main cast members. Hopefully we’ll see Jin and Sun find each other… Hurley, Syid, the Ben and Locke story etc in upcoming episodes as it’s coming to the end of the season.
John Cabrera on 04 May 2009 at 11:42 am #
Oh Smackers, I never said Penny was overreacting. No doubt about it, that’s a realistic reaction to a loved one being shot. As was the doctor’s response that they’ll do all they can. But since this is a story, the events the writers choose to show us, inform how we should engage the episode. Lots of realistic things happen on the island that we never see (people going to the bathroom for one), but when we are shown something, we have to assume it’s a part of the greater story, that it has significance… especially if the stakes are that high (a character dying) And by showing us Penny’s intense fear and the doctor’s urgency/uncertainty, we’re being asked by the writers to fear the worst. The only problem with that is after five seasons, they’ve shown many people dying and surviving from much worse. I just doubt many viewers actually feared Desmond would die… and so all of that seemed extraneous to me.
Mike on 04 May 2009 at 3:43 pm #
Per the Lost audio podcast about changing the future: Drop a pebble in a stream, it gets covered up, drop a boulder in the stream and the stream splits. Whether or not the future can really be changed is the big question for the rest of the season.
John Cabrera on 04 May 2009 at 3:49 pm #
Mike, well as you know, I believe that it can… or rather, it can and it can’t… alternate/parallel universes. I’m already outlining a post based on the comments from this one. I’m gonna try to explain how some of what they’ve already shown us supports it.