SYTYCD-FDL Bonus Pick Post – Week 1
OKAY BIG UPDATE: I’ll make this quick:
- Noelle will not be dancing tonight.
- Her partner Russell will dance with a choreographer.
- A female WILL be eliminated tonight, but it won’t be Noelle.
- Noelle will have a week to recover, if she can’t, then the eliminated girl from Week 1 comes back and Noelle is off the show.
- How does this effect you? If you picked Noelle and she does not recover by next week, then she will be the Week 1 person voted off, not the girl who goes home tonight.
- If you want to change your picks, you have exactly 45 minutes (5pm PST).
- I may include a small bonus to those who get it right tonight but lose it if Noelle drops out… I just need to figure out what would be fair.
- Sorry for all of this confusion… but you know you love it.
Here’s my source.
BREAKING NEWS: Read this bit of news about two of the dancers before making your picks. And if you’ve already submitted, you have the chance to change your picks until 2pm PST…that’s 5pm on the east coast… and to be honest, I’m lenient, so as long as the show doesn’t air on east coast, if you get it in a little late, I won’t deny you.
This is the first Bonus Pick Post of the FDL. It is also the official entry into the game and required for all players. Please read the rules carefully.
- Submit a comment to THIS POST with one guy and one girl that you think are going home on Tuesday night’s show. There will not be an elimination show this week, due to the World Series (American Baseball), so the judges will be watching the performances and making their decision that night.
- Make sure that in the comment’s Name Field you write something that matches you to the email you’ll be sending next week with your full picks. Including your email in the comment’s Email Field, for example, would be the best way (Your email address will NOT be posted in the comment or anywhere else publicly). Otherwise you’ll have to be sure when you send me your full card of picks that you include a name that’s the same as the one you include with your comment. If you don’t, I may have a hard time figuring out who is who.
- In the comment field that says website, include the web address you want to represent your online presence (ie your blog, twitter, tumblr, facebook, blip etc.) This is optional, of course.
- Leave this comment anytime between now and 2pm Pacific Standard Time this Tuesday (10/27/2009)
- If you change your mind after submitting, no problem. Just submit another comment the same way with different name(s). I’ll accept the later of the two as your official picks.
Doing the above will officially enter you into the game. Then you’ll have until 12pm PST on the day of Week 2′s performance show to submit your full card of picks to dance@johncabrera.com. Please read the rules on how to format that submission as well as how these Week 1 picks will be factored into your total points.
Week 2 is also likely to have no elimination show and be judged the same way. I haven’t decided yet whether I’ll include a Bonus Pick for that week if it doesn’t… but just check back here. I’ll post something either way.
I actually think there’s something interesting about the judges choosing who goes home that night. They aren’t going to have much time to decide, so theories that the judges rig things may play less of a roll this elimination. If those theories do play a role, I think it’ll be even more obvious, because they’ll have less time to come up with a realistic excuse.
Okay, so let the FDL begin. Submit your Week 1 guy and girl dancers below as a comment. I suggest doing it sooner rather than later, if you’ve already decided. I won’t post anyone’s comment until after the show airs, so you won’t be able influence your decision by seeing who others have picked. But I WIIILLL! Hehe!
And if you’d like to catch up on the past audition episodes and you don’t have them recorded, Register here at my blog, then send me a tweet, message, email (my first name AT johncabrera.com), etc. saying you’ll be joining the FDL, and I’ll give you permission to read special posts designed to help you catch up.
Good luck.
45 Responses to “SYTYCD-FDL Bonus Pick Post – Week 1”

BabsiS on 25 Oct 2009 at 11:42 am #
My picks for week 1 are:
Bianca and Peter.
Jenn on 26 Oct 2009 at 11:22 am #
My Picks:
Karen Hauer
Peter Sabasino
chia_wombat on 26 Oct 2009 at 4:11 pm #
Okay, my prediction for the first to go out:Peter & Noelle.
I heard that Billy Bell caught the swine flu! Goo!
Rae on 26 Oct 2009 at 5:12 pm #
Based on what I saw tonight, I think Victor would go. However, the last minute change in people leads me to think Brandon is at a severe disadvantage so…
Brandon Dumlao
Ashleigh Di Lello
k8hinote on 26 Oct 2009 at 5:35 pm #
I have no idea how I’m supposed to choose! I almost decided to bail, but I’m just gonna go with my gut. I’m already totally second guessing myself, but oh well.
My Week 1 picks are Bianca and Legacy.
Elizabeth Allen on 26 Oct 2009 at 5:36 pm #
Girl- Bianca
Guy- Victor
sorano916 on 26 Oct 2009 at 5:59 pm #
Boo to not knowing how Brandon dancing… so I have to say “bye” to him.
Boy: Brandon Dumlao
Girl: Ellenore Scott
Jessiy on 26 Oct 2009 at 7:19 pm #
Kevin and Mollee
Caryl on 26 Oct 2009 at 8:13 pm #
Tuesday 10.27 elimination guess: Bianca & Kevin
k8mclin on 26 Oct 2009 at 8:24 pm #
Ok. I’m a little frightened. I hate being wrong but you’d think after 35 fucking years of abject failure I’d be used to it. Just kidding. Like 25/35.
Phillip and Ariana
I think my husband, Andrew, wants to play too. So you will probably hear from him later. I must not let him influence my decisions, so I am commenting before he gets home. I keep trying to think up some terribly witty Ryan and Ashleigh comparison, but I keep rewinding the Coldplay dance and mourning the loss of Billy. He was about to be my SYTYCD boy toy for the season, but now I’m looking elsewhere. Victor? Peter?
The top twenty show was the tits, btw. What a great idea. I loved almost every dance.
/rambling
Rebecca on 26 Oct 2009 at 8:51 pm #
To go home tomorrow I’m gonna say Ashleigh and Peter.
the_melmel on 26 Oct 2009 at 8:56 pm #
Im so excited about the SYTYCD-FDL!! Here are my two picks for elimination week one: For the gus im going to go with Victor Smalley, and for the girls im going with Mollee Gray.
Vince & Anne on 26 Oct 2009 at 9:22 pm #
Peter, Noel
Vanalam on 26 Oct 2009 at 9:46 pm #
For my picks to go home this week:
I really like Legacy. He’s AMAZING at what he does (skimming across the floor on only your hands, SERIOUSLY?!), but I think the judges were giving him their version of a consolation prize by putting him in the Top 20 to begin with. There are other very strong hip-hop dancers in the competition this year who can also seem to be able to pick up choreography well (something we haven’t seen as much of in some past seasons). Besides that, we already know their bringing in another hip-hop dancer to replace Billy (which makes me think they might be getting rid of one). Another season, I would have thought Legacy would last longer. This season, he’s my pick to go in week 1. Sorry, Legacy. I still love you.
The girl to go home is a much harder decision for me, mainly because we’ve seen so little of so many of them. Purely based on numbers, I’m going to guess it’s going to be one of the contemporary girls. Arianna, Noelle and Kathryn have all received almost 0 face time, but that doesn’t necessarily mean anything when it’s not the audience choosing, I guess. Hmmm…I’m going to go with Arianna. I’m sure she’s amazing and she may completely prove me wrong tomorrow (and I may have to eat 6 points later), but we’ve seen less of her than any of the other dancers (which may mean she have less favor with Mr. Executive Producer?) and that’s all I really have to go on right now.
So hard to choose without seeing a performance show and the couples! This is going to be a tough season. Looking forward to it.
Mandy on 26 Oct 2009 at 10:06 pm #
My Week 1 Bonus picks are Russell and Ashleigh.
jennhoney on 26 Oct 2009 at 10:39 pm #
I have no idea. I may change my picks all day …
Kathryn McCormick
Phillip Attmore
Good luck Larkers!
Jules on 26 Oct 2009 at 11:04 pm #
okay, just because I can’t even remember them, I’m going with Ariana and Jacob, this week. xoxoxo
chad rullman on 27 Oct 2009 at 1:28 am #
Alright. Damn near shooting blindly, but here’s my guess for Round 1: Peter Sabasino & Kathryn McCormick
Melissa on 27 Oct 2009 at 6:18 am #
Ashley and Philip? I have no idea. Perhaps it would have been safer to guess two of the contestants whose names I can’t remember, as their failure to make an impression must not be a good sign. But I’ve got the pig influenza and I’m using that as an excuse to be lazy and not look up forgotten names. So Ashley and Philip it is. Thanks for running the FDL again, John. So fun!!!! Even if I’m terrible at it.
MzHokie on 27 Oct 2009 at 6:30 am #
Philip – tap dancer
Ashley – ballroom dancer
Melissa on 27 Oct 2009 at 6:49 am #
Hi! My picks (or wild guesses, really) for week 1 elimination are Peter and Ariana.
Ducky on 27 Oct 2009 at 7:06 am #
I’m really bad at these fantasy picks, the last time I did one for Idol, I was off by a Ruben Studdard…
The Girl: Ashleigh DiLello
The Guy: Ryan DiLello
I can’t stand this husband/wife duo – let’s get rid of them so we can concentrate on the dancers we actually like to “fantasize” about!
Yan on 27 Oct 2009 at 8:58 am #
Pauline Mata
Phillip Atmore
Sophia on 27 Oct 2009 at 9:57 am #
SYTYCD-FDL Bonus picks:
Phillip and Mollee will be going home
Andrew Linington on 27 Oct 2009 at 9:58 am #
My two picks for the first week:
Girl: Noelle
Guy: Peter
Ellen on 27 Oct 2009 at 10:08 am #
Week 1 Guy: Phillip Attmore
Week 1 Gal: Kathryn McCormick
Sean Gunn on 27 Oct 2009 at 10:08 am #
My picks for week 1 are Peter and Ariana.
Itzel on 27 Oct 2009 at 10:12 am #
Hopeful farewell to: Ariana Debose & Legacy Perez (fingers crossed!)
Michael Muhney on 27 Oct 2009 at 10:12 am #
Girl is Noelle and guy is Phillip
Shannon ( EMOjunky) on 27 Oct 2009 at 10:19 am #
Okay – my first SYTYCD-FDL picks! my two that I think will be going home – based on nothing since I still haven’t even watched last weeks last vegas ep – but I’m going with Brendan Dumlao – since he’s a late addition and the judges didn’t originally pick him – so why would they keep him over others they DID originally pick – and Mollee Gray – no real reason – just don’t like the way she spells her name and can’t really remember her…okay – those are my picks
Kristen on 27 Oct 2009 at 10:31 am #
I think Legacy and Ashleigh will go home tonight.
kelseroo on 27 Oct 2009 at 10:33 am #
Gah! I really have no idea. Oh well, here are my picks: Bianca Revels (she doesn’t seem strong enough, even in tap) and Victor Smalley (I could not decide on a guy, so I went with the most forgettable one for me).
Johnny Hugel on 27 Oct 2009 at 11:06 am #
First Cuts: Phillip & Ashleigh
caffrin on 27 Oct 2009 at 11:17 am #
Assuming Noelle is out, I’m sticking with Peter and changing my girl vote to Kathryn.
Amrie on 27 Oct 2009 at 11:44 am #
I’ve gone back and forth about this. I originally said Noelle, and now with the word that Melanie’s dancing in Noelle’s place and that a decision will be made later, I’m still tempted to say that the judges will say Noelle can’t dance going forward, and she’ll be the girl ouster, but that she’ll be replaced SO I’ve decided to change from Noelle to Karen (the ballroomer).
Kaitlin on 27 Oct 2009 at 11:47 am #
female cut is Katheryn and male cut is Jacob.
Thanks!
Monica on 27 Oct 2009 at 11:49 am #
I hope I’m in time. I’m new to this, so I’m not sure if I’m doing this right. If not, no worries, just disregard.
My picks for first 2 dancers going home are:
Phillip and Mollee
Those could be wishful thinking on my part, I don’t know. I have no clue this season because there have been crazy changes last minute. I just wanted to play ’cause I love this show and it sounded fun.
Thanks for putting it all together.
Reneemarie on 27 Oct 2009 at 11:51 am #
For tonight I pick Mollee and Phillip to go home.
Strunkette on 27 Oct 2009 at 11:51 am #
I WANT these guys to go home so they will be my bonus picks.
Phillip & Ashleigh
Picking my whole FNL bracket is really hard! (Which is a good sign….hopefully this will be the best season since Season 2!)
Carmen on 27 Oct 2009 at 12:00 pm #
I finally made my picks for tonight’s show:
Phillip Attmore
Ashleigh Di Lello
well, i hope i’m not totally wrong
Heather on 27 Oct 2009 at 12:46 pm #
What the heck, I’ll try it out this year.
I’m going to say for tonight:
Victor Smalley
Ariana Debose
Utter guesswork.
Alyssa on 27 Oct 2009 at 1:42 pm #
I changed my mind sorry! I’m gonna go with Phillip and Ariana
PlaidGirl on 27 Oct 2009 at 2:21 pm #
Can I vote for Cat Deely and Tice Diorio to be voted off?
Just kidding! Ok here are my picks: Mollee Gray and Peter Sabasino
Nathan on 27 Oct 2009 at 3:25 pm #
Week 1 Girl Going Home: Pauline
Week 1 Guy Going Home: Victor
John Cabrera on 27 Oct 2009 at 3:38 pm #
Guy: Phillip
Girl: Ashleigh